Mariella Pizza in New York City

Mariella Pizza in New York City
4.5 / 5
50 reviews

965 Lexington Ave, Frnt A, New York City, NY 10021-5113, New York City

Overview

Cuisine
  • Pizza
  • Italian

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Is this the same chain from the Mariella’s on Lex? I love that place.

No

How far do you deliver

5 miles

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Mariella Pizza
PR
Pavinder Rana
google
09.18.2021
5/5

The store itself looked clean and had a nice aesthetic. There are plenty of seats. The pizza tasted amazing and the staff was friendly.

Mariella Pizza
LV
Luz Valenzuela
google
11.11.2018
3/5

Pizza is good but the place is dirty it wasn't like that before.... really they need to take care of that place!!!!

Mariella Pizza
JC
Jonathan Cung
google
10.21.2018
2/5

Sure the pizza is decent here, one of the better grandma slices out in NYC but...watch out for the inconsistent pricing. I was quoted at $21+ for six slices of the grandma, the guy behind the counter tries to sell me a whole pie and quotes me $23+ for the pie. In what world does this math equate? I implore anyone who visits this establishment to watch the prices carefully.

Mariella Pizza
GB
Gamer Boy 2.0
google
10.01.2018
5/5

Great pizza. Fast service.

Mariella Pizza
BW
Bobby Watson
google
09.16.2018
5/5

One of the best slices in the City .

Mariella Pizza
DB
David Berkowitz
google
08.25.2018
4/5

Very good pizza - some of the better Sicilian I’ve had and top notch plain slices. Nothing I’ll be craving but would definitely return when in the neighborhood

Mariella Pizza
HC
Harry Cardillo
google
08.13.2018
5/5

Tasty pizza. Good prices. No nonsense. It was a great place to have a nice chill family dinner with no complications. Quiet area to sit and eat in the back. Wish they had gluten free options but I can't complain.

Mariella Pizza
RR
Ronald Ross
google
07.15.2018
3/5

Stopped at this place on a whim. It was just ok. It certainly wasn't the worst pizza ever but also was no where near the best. The crust was a little dry. Not a ton of cheese either. But sauce was tasty enough. The staff were helpful, friendly, and attentive. There was plenty of room to sit and eat, with a room in the back as well. Very close to Metro Station too.

Mariella Pizza
TW
Tiffany Wilson
google
06.27.2018
5/5

Loved this pizza several years ago when I worked in the Time Warner building. I was very sad when they moved. I haven't been able to get to Mariella's during my most recent visits, but it's a pizza spot I still hold very dear to my heart. I hope to be back to enjoy a delicious slice!

Mariella Pizza
AB
ANTHONY BERRIOS
google
06.22.2018
4/5

Traditional Italian pizza shop...

Mariella Pizza
EJ
Elizabeth J
google
06.19.2018
4/5

This has some of the best New York style pizza on the upper east side. They have reasonable pies and they sell slices.

Mariella Pizza
LH
Lisa Hoskins
google
05.18.2018
5/5

Grandma pizza rocks. Don't know what it is, but it tastes really good.

Mariella Pizza
RP
Roseann Porcasi
google
04.21.2018
5/5

Best grandma slice ever

Mariella Pizza
OctavioChavez
google
03.15.2018
4/5

I was visiting NYC from California and waow I wasn't expecting anything out of this world but the cheese slice I had was delicious. I dont know what it was but I tasted a difference in the cheese compared to what I've had anywhere else in the country. Maybe it was because I was really hungry but I'll definitely be coming back. Only thing I suggest is keeping the place cleaner.

Mariella Pizza
LR
L. R.
google
03.07.2018
4/5

Have only tried there Pizza. But it is decent. Crust not too thick nor too thin. Greasy but also I think that there seems to be more sauce than cheese. 1-10, I give it a 7.

Mariella Pizza
DC
David Conover
google
02.24.2018
4/5

I got hungry in Central Park and quickly consulted Google maps for a location and found this. My girlfriendb and I both enjoyed our pizza with the prices not being unfair for city prices. The slices are very good and has a pizza joint atmosphere that you could want. Id recommend this place for a quick bite for lunch or if you need a snack.

Mariella Pizza
AT
Andre Torres
google
01.23.2018
5/5

You can't go wrong with there food

Mariella Pizza
MP
Maxine Proctor
google
01.15.2018
5/5

Pretty good pizza. Many styles to choose from. . Price is good.

Mariella Pizza
AN
Aaron Ng
google
01.02.2018
5/5

Very nice people and pizza is pretty good in terms of quality and size. The crust wasn't too bready nor too thin. A touch on the pricey side. They have a TV inside and ok seating for a quick bite to eat.

Mariella Pizza
AA
Andrey Aparshev
google
11.10.2017
5/5

Staff is friendly. Not too many available slices of pizza, but what do they have is pretty good. Carbonara is also good.

Mariella Pizza
MS
Margaret Stuart
google
11.03.2017
5/5

So, so yum, and fast service!

Mariella Pizza
LS
Lolita Santos
google
11.01.2017
5/5

Best abuela pizza in NYC

Mariella Pizza
CH
Curtis Hubner
google
09.18.2017
5/5

Best pizza and chicken rolls in NYC. Authentic.

Mariella Pizza
lh
lol haha
google
09.14.2017
5/5

Great slices, good price.

Mariella Pizza
DB
Des Brownlie
google
07.27.2017
4/5

Great Chicken Parmigiana, good size of sandwich and very tasty

Mariella Pizza
MS
Marshall Shaffer
google
07.01.2017
4/5

There was a lot of confusion in terms of who had taken my order, which was a little frustrating. But overall, the pizza was tasty.

Mariella Pizza
ir
israel roman jr
google
05.15.2017
5/5

Pizza is good, service is quick, and they've renovated the place very beautifully.

Mariella Pizza
MM
Marsha McGregor
google
04.13.2017
4/5

The pizza is great, the staff is friendly. The only reason for 4 stars and not 5 is that an attendant is needed to clean dining area. You can't rely on your customers to clean up behind themselves because THEY DON'T.

Mariella Pizza
PV
Pedro Vasquez
google
04.09.2017
4/5

Always a good dining experience.

Mariella Pizza
TK
TOM Kirby
google
03.19.2017
5/5

Great crispy crust, lite and a nice sauce.

Mariella Pizza
PS
Pedro Serrano
google
02.25.2017
4/5

Really good pizza. Especially the Grandma pizza. Inexpensive and they serve beer too

Mariella Pizza
CS
Charles Simons
google
02.23.2017
4/5

Good pizza regardless of their uptown prices

Mariella Pizza
JJ
Janette Jackson
google
02.14.2017
4/5

It was one of the best pizza that I tasted. The crust was amazingly delicious.

Mariella Pizza
M0
Mg 0
google
02.05.2017
5/5

Fresh, tasty pizza with a hefty topping of gooey mozzarella. The veggie slice is near perfection, with a crisp crust and a variety of vegetables over a swath of savoury sauce. Large seating area in the back, and (yay !) no music playing

Mariella Pizza
JT
Jose Torres
google
02.05.2017
4/5

A satisfying pizza experience!Mariella Pizza delivers a fresh, quick, and filling pizza by the slice or by the pie. The have a wide variety. The supreme and Hawaiian were right on point. The staff is also pretty friendly.Would visit them again To try their other toppings

Mariella Pizza
VK
Viki Kuo
google
01.07.2017
4/5

Great pizza. Chill air-conditioning.

Mariella Pizza
JK
Judy Kulsum
google
11.01.2016
4/5

Pizza is really good. Service is pretty fast considering how busy they usually are

Mariella Pizza
MM
Michelle Mitchell
google
10.02.2016
5/5

We are here from Florida for a girl’s weekend and one of us is riding a scooter that needs to be charged. We went into Mariellas, they were so kind and let us plug in for hours!!!! We did order some slices and they were awesome too! 5 stars all day 🍕🍕Thanks guys

Mariella Pizza
MK
Maria K
google
09.26.2016
5/5

I'm very picky when it comes to pizza. But Mariella has quality pizza. The cheese is not excessively oily. The sauce has a good flavor and there is a healthy ratio of cheese to sauce. And the crust is just right.

Mariella Pizza
SC
Scott Crews
google
09.12.2016
5/5

Cheese pizza was very good, some of the best I had in town. No line, easy order, and seating in the back for 30.

Mariella Pizza
MV
María Virginia Velázquez
google
07.27.2016
5/5

It is a nice place to eat fast, good and affordable italo-american food.

Mariella Pizza
JV
Jc Vargas
google
07.08.2016
5/5

Its the Best pizza I have ever had by far, fresh ingredients and outstanding service is what this restaurant is about all about. Flavors are authentic and delicious, if you visit Manhattan you got to stop by here and you will surely have the best pizza NY has to offer. Needless to say, the place looks very clean and neat. Will visit again

Mariella Pizza
AG
Andrew Greene
google
07.07.2016
1/5

Slow, lazy, unfriendly service. Pizza quality is barely above dollar slice quality. High prices for below average food. No soul except for the cycling jerseys on the walls.

Mariella Pizza
HW
Hans Wurscht
google
04.15.2016
5/5

The best Pizza near the Central Park!Very competent support about the pizza, also in fluent german. 5/7

Mariella Pizza
AP
Amy Polansky
google
04.07.2016
5/5

Every time I visit NYC, this is always my go-to restaurant for some great food. The restaurant inside besides mariella offers a wide variety of items for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, all of them tasting absolutely great! The prices are exactly what they should be, and the food is worth the money. The pizza is of good quality, and there are different kinds for whatever you're feeling that day. Overall a wonderful place to sit in and enjoy NYC.

Mariella Pizza
PJ
Phil Jackson
google
03.10.2016
5/5

Grandma Pizza & Garlic knots soon as I walk in they know what I want. They take good care of me and the food is amazing. Going there today for lunch 😊

Mariella Pizza
HC
Henry Castillo
google
02.08.2016
5/5

Everything they make here is AMAZING & DELICIOUS.

Mariella Pizza
KT
Kevin Tipton
google
02.02.2016
4/5

Good Late Night Slices but not worth it sober. Very limited English staff which is fine but hard to order. I was up charged for not being a local. So overall good place to stumble to but not to seek it out.

Mariella Pizza
CW
Christian W
google
01.13.2016
5/5

They serve big dishes and for fair rates. nice owner. Highly recommended.

Mariella Pizza
av
arthur van
google
01.09.2016
5/5

They have one of the best spaghetti meet ball in the area, whenever I'm working in the neighborhood that's my go to place, don't forget to try the sausage roll, uhh "Delicioso"

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 12122492065

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!